Friday April 18, 2014   Last updated 06:21AM
max
°
min
°

On Air Now | Radio Waatea

06:00am - 07:00am
24th Hour
Ruia Aperahama
Tribunal essential for contemporary justice
Getty Images. Annette Sykes.

Share to Email
Share to RSS
Share to Print

A senior treaty lawyer says a call to scrap the Waitangi Tribunal at the end of the historical claims process ignores the history of Māori being denied justice.

In a radio debate, Victoria University law professor Matthew Palmer argued that contemporary breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi should be dealt with by the High Court.

Annette Sykes says the general courts have never warmed to Māori perspectives, and that is unlikely to change any time soon.

She says groups can't get legal aid for civil actions at High Court level, so claimants have to carry their own costs - which is why very few treaty cases were taken after Te Heuheu Tukino lost his case in the Privy Council on whether the treaty was part of New Zealand law.

"In another case, Tamehana Te Korokai, which was a case where the water rights were tested here in Te Arawa, my family had to sell land to pay the water bills and there is a real hesitancy in the history of these kinds of matters for Māori to participate in the general courts," Ms Sykes says.

She says the experience of the last 30 years indicates the Waitangi Tribunal should be given expanded powers to make more binding recommendations on contemporary issues.




Copyright © 2013, Uma Broadcasting Ltd


2949

Comments


Post comment:

Name*
Email*
Will not be published

Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)
In order to assist us in reducing spam, please type the characters you see:
spam control image
I have read and accepted the terms and conditions

These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to webmaster@waatea603am.co.nz

WEBAD - Breakfast with Dale

News

Manako 17/04/2014-pt 1-6 Te Hira Paenga
1 of the 3 hopefuls for the Maori Party Tamaki Seat.
Manako 17/04/2014-pt 3-6 Rangi Maclean
1 of the 3 prospects for the Maori Party Tamaki seat.
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Cath Cardiff
Cath Cardiff | Top kapa haka groups, dance company Black Grace and writer Witi Ihimaera are among more than 200 New Zealand artists who will take part in arts festivals in Edinburgh this August.
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Shane Jones
Labour List MP Shane Jones with his weekly political overview of political events appealing to and involving te ao Maori
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Hone Harawira
Mana held their AGM last weekend and with sepculation on the relationship between Mana and Kim Dotcoms Internet Party Hone Harawira talks with Dale Husband
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Kevin Hackwell
Kevin Hackwell | Independent conservation organisation Forest and Bird says the Board of Inquiry that this week granted consent for the Ruataniwha irrigation dam has failed to account for the overall environmental damage the project would cause, if it is
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Ray Ahipene Mercer
Ray Ahipene Mercer | The New Zealand Coalition to End Homelessness (NZCEH) congratulates the Wellington City Council who endorsed ˜Te Mahana Homelessness Strategy. The strategy is unique in incorporating a Maori perspective alongside a best practice
Te Wahanga Parakuihi 17042014 - Ben Dalton
Ministry of Primary Industries Ben Dalton | The Federation of Maori Authorities is welcoming the announcement that agri-business projects it put forward on behalf of its membership and Maori farmers have been awarded grants from the Sustainable Farming F
Harawira's deal with Dotcom raises issues
The criticism around Hone Harawira doing a deal with Kim Dotcom is not only unfair but raises questions of hypocrisy and racism.
Trust needs shakeup
Unlike many critics I refuse to accept that the Kohanga Reo National Trust is an organisation that reeks of corruption.
Debate makes MP damaged goods
The polls might be stacked against Labour at this stage but the way they have pursued the Judith Collins story over the milk company debate shows they are not out of the race by a long way.
0
WaateaFuneral
PlunketSm
TMP2
p waateap listenp podcastp rssp facebookp twittercontactus

Submit


Glossary

Subscribe

To receive regular updates from Waatea News.