Monday November 24, 2014   Last updated 20:57PM
max
°
min
°

On Air Now | Radio Waatea

08:00pm - 10:00pm
Whakamahana
Pacific Curls
Tribunal essential for contemporary justice
Getty Images. Annette Sykes.

Share to Email
Share to RSS
Share to Print

A senior treaty lawyer says a call to scrap the Waitangi Tribunal at the end of the historical claims process ignores the history of Māori being denied justice.

In a radio debate, Victoria University law professor Matthew Palmer argued that contemporary breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi should be dealt with by the High Court.

Annette Sykes says the general courts have never warmed to Māori perspectives, and that is unlikely to change any time soon.

She says groups can't get legal aid for civil actions at High Court level, so claimants have to carry their own costs - which is why very few treaty cases were taken after Te Heuheu Tukino lost his case in the Privy Council on whether the treaty was part of New Zealand law.

"In another case, Tamehana Te Korokai, which was a case where the water rights were tested here in Te Arawa, my family had to sell land to pay the water bills and there is a real hesitancy in the history of these kinds of matters for Māori to participate in the general courts," Ms Sykes says.

She says the experience of the last 30 years indicates the Waitangi Tribunal should be given expanded powers to make more binding recommendations on contemporary issues.




Copyright © 2013, Uma Broadcasting Ltd


Comments


Post comment:

Name*
Email*
Will not be published

Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)
In order to assist us in reducing spam, please type the characters you see:
spam control image
I have read and accepted the terms and conditions

These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to webmaster@waatea603am.co.nz
WEBAD - MSA 2014
WEBAD - ETangata
TWP 24112014 - Willie Jackson
CEO Mankau Urban Maori Authority Willie Jackson | A High Court judge had ruled that the process used to select one of the maataka representatives on Aucklands Independent Maori Statutory Board was flawed and needed to be done again. He said in picking incumbent member Tony Kake over Willie Jackson, the selection panel which only included mana whenua representatives failed to show it had considered mataawaka views.
Paakiwaha 24112014 - 2 John Key and Peter Lucas Jones
John Key spoke with Peter Lucas Jones from Te Hiku Radio after the release of Te Paparahi O Te Raki Report. He talks about sovereignty, mandated bodies to negoiate on behalf of Ngapuhi and other issues
TWP 24112014 - Te Ururoa Flavell
Minister Maori Development Te Ururoa Flavell | Flaws in deciding members of the Independent Maori Statutory Board, Miraka do business with China and more kaupapa
TWP 24112014 - Professor Ross Hemara
Professor Ross Hemara | Honourary Doctate for Chinese First Lady frm Massey University
Manako 24112014 - Pt 2 Kelvin Davis
Tai Tokerau MP Kelvin Davis | A new deputy leader for Labour will be announced this morning
Manako 24112014 - Pt 4 Rob Ruha
Ngati Porou / Whanau A Apanui Rob Ruha | Winner at the Vodafone Music Awards Best Maori Album 2014
Manako 24112014 - Pt 3 Justin Tipa
Justin Tipa | Arahura Marae opening in Ngai Tahu over the weekend
TWP 24112014 - Kingi Smiler
Kingi Smiler from Miraka Ltd | China's largest dairy company, China Mengniu, will add New Zealand UHT products to its portfolio by joint venturing with Maori-owned Miraka dairy processor and the Shanghai Pengxin dairy farming company.
Little's Time
OPINION: Andrew Little has to do a lot if he is to make Labour a formidable opposition, giving them any hope of toppling National in three years’ time. Little was on Tuesday voted as the man to lead Labour into a new era of politics - this was on the back of major support he got from his union mates.
The myths white people tell themselves
OPINION: John Key's extraordinary statements last week on NZ History in relation to the Waitangi Tribunal's finding that Maori did not cede sovereignty when they signed the Treaty in 1840 is a case study in ignorance, cultural arrogance and political posturing.
Waitangi Tribunal ruling enshrines Treaty as a living document
OPINION: The most significant thing about the Waitangi Tribunal ruling last week that Maori did not sign away Tino Rangatiratanga in 1840 is that it has reset with immediacy the role of the Treaty into the modern day.
0
WaateaFuneral


 
TMP2
p waateap listenp podcastp rssp facebookp twittercontactus

Submit


Glossary

Subscribe

To receive regular updates from Waatea News.